Health Care Utilization and Expenditures of Patients with Diabetes Comorbid with Depression Disorder: A National Population-Based Cohort Study
Article information
Abstract
Objective
The study investigated to compare health care utilization and expenditures between diabetic patients with and without depression in Taiwan.
Methods
Health care utilization and expenditure among diabetic patients with and without depression disorder during 2000 and 2004 were examined using Taiwan's population-based National Health Insurance claims database. Health care utilization included outpatient visits and the use of inpatient services, and health expenditures were outpatient, inpatient, and total medical expenditures. Moreover, general estimation equation models were used for analyzing the factors associated with outpatient visits and expenditures. Multiple logistic regression analysis was applied for identifying the factors associated with hospitalization.
Results
The average annual outpatient visits and annual total medical expenditures in the study period were 44.23–52.20; NT$87,496–133,077 and 30.75–32.92; NT$64,411–80,955 for diabetic patients with and without depression. After adjustment for covariates, our results revealed that gender and complication were associated with out-patient visits. Moreover, the time factor was associated with the total medical expenditure, and residential urbanization and complication factors were associated with hospitalization.
Conclusion
Health care utilization and expenditures for diabetic patients with depression were significantly higher than those without depression. Sex, complications, time, and urbanization are the factors associated with health care utilization and expenditures.
INTRODUCTION
Diabetes mellitus, a chronic and disabling disease, majorly contributes to disability-adjusted life years.12 Similarly, major depressive disorder (MDD) is a leading cause of disability among chronic medical conditions.34 The World Health Organization categorizes depression as one of the most disabling clinical diagnosis estimated to affect approximately 340 million people worldwide.5 Depression disorder affects the productivity of workers through high absenteeism and reduced on-the-job output and can lead to disability.6 Diabetes mellitus (DM) is an epidemic disease in the world. Marked changes in human health behaviors and lifestyle have resulted in higher incidence and prevalence of DM.7 It has been recently estimated that the global prevalence of diabetes is 8.3%.8 DM is a prevalent disease that causes significant morbidity and mortality and is associated with substantial care utilization and expenditure910 DM and its complications impose a heavy burden on personal and public health globally. The number of persons with diabetes is also rising because of population growth, aging, urbanization, and increasing prevalence of obesity and physical inactivity. The potential for increase in persons with diabetes is greatest in Asia.811 Type 2 DM has become an important public health threat for the ethnic Chinese population living in mainland China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Singapore, with a prevalence of one-fifth of the adult population.89 Given the genetic susceptibility and rapid westernization of food and lifestyle, a striking increase in incidence and prevalence of type 2 DM is anticipated.812
Comorbid mental and physical illness, often categorized as “chronic illness with complexity (CIC),” is a new and emerging research area. CIC is defined as multiple chronic conditions occurring simultaneously regardless of the causal pathways and associations.1314 Mental illnesses comorbid with physical illnesses are often considered discordant1516 because of the challenges involved with self-management and the varying treatment regimens for both types of illnesses. For example, the prognosis of diabetes largely depends on the efficiency of routine self-management. Similar to other chronic diseases, comorbid mental illnesses can substantially affect diabetes management.17 Depressive symptoms, depression and anxiety disorders, and diabetes-specific distress are common in patients with diabetes. All factors are associated with several bio behavioral variables, including poor disease management, high health care costs, and mortality.1718
Many studies have discussed the health care utilization and expenditures of patients with diabetes comorbid with physical complications.19202122 However, few studies have focused on mental illnesses in patients with diabetes, although these patients are more predisposed to anxiety and depression than the general population.23242526 Most studies on the association between depression and diabetes have been conducted in Western countries.172728293031 Very few evidence is present on the aforementioned association in Asian countries, particularly in China, although analyses from other cultures are a critical component of epidemiology. Cultural factors and explanatory disease models may differ in patients from Asian and Western countries, which affects the ability of patients to report the symptoms of mental illnesses and disease presentation. As stated by Lloyd et al.32 in a review article, cultural diversity must be considered while assessing patients with mental illnesses.1 According to our review of relevant literature, thus far, few studies have elaborated on the time factor associated with health care utilization and expenditures in patients with diabetes. Hence, the present study investigated health care utilization and expenditures of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression in a clinical setting and identified the associated factors.
METHODS
National health insurance program and data source
Taiwan's National Health Insurance (NHI) program is a mandatory, single-payer system established in 1995 under the NHI Administration (NHIA); approximately 98% of all Taiwanese residents are enrolled in the program, and almost all medical care providers in Taiwan, including those employed at medical and primary care centers, are contracted by the NHIA to provide outpatient and inpatient services. Through a fee-for-service payment system, all health care providers fill monthly service claims to the NHI to get reimbursement for their medical fees. These claims include inpatient, ambulatory, and home care, and information such as patient demographics (age and sex), clinical details [disease and procedure codes based on the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM)], and health care utilization and expenditure (hospital days, drug use, and costs).
Our study was conducted retrospectively using a study cohort drawing from a random sample in the National Health Research Institutes (NHRI) database from 2000 to 2004. The cohort was randomly selected from the population that enrolled in the NHI in 2000 (n=23,735,407). Excluding those from the uninsured population, a sample group of 200,432 patients represented 1% of the total NHI database. No significant differences were observed in age, sex, or the average insured payroll-related amount between the random sample and whole population. Although the administrative claims database has limitations regarding the accuracy of diagnostic coding,3334 the database has been validated and research based on the database has been previously published.232425353637
Definitions of diabetes and depression disorder
Patients with at least two service claims for diabetes (ICD-9-CM 250) for ambulatory care or with one service claim for inpatient care between 2000 and 2004 were defined as having diabetes.2324253538 To reduce possible coding and diagnostic errors, these patients were classified into type 1 diabetes according to ICD-9-CM 250.x1 and 250.x3 and type 2 diabetes according to ICD-9-CM 250.x0 and 250.x2. Patients with at least one service claim between 2000 and 2004 for either ambulatory or inpatient care with a principal diagnosis of depression (ICD-9-CM 296.2x, 296.3x, 296.82, 300.4, 309.0, 309.1, and 311) were defined as having depression.23 Total 5,636 patients with diabetes were identified, including 144 (2.55%) patients with depression.
Health care utilization and expenditures
Health care utilization included outpatient visits and hospital admission per person per year. Outpatients included those who visited physician clinics and hospital outpatient departments. Hospital admission was defined as admission to a general or psychiatric hospital.
Healthcare expenditure included outpatient, inpatient, and total medical expenditures per person per year. Outpatient expenditure included payments for office-based provider visits and hospital outpatient visits. Outpatient health expenditures consisted of physician fee, medication, laboratory exams, and others. Inpatient expenditures included 14 items, including medication, room, procedure, imaging, and others.3539 To reflect the real monetary value, the mean expenditures were adjusted using the consumer price index for the Taiwanese currency in 2004.
Age, income, time, and other covariates
Patient demographics characteristics included age, sex, urbanization, and income, whereas disease characteristics included types of complications and diabetes. Patient ages were calculated as the year difference of mid-year (June 30) and patient birthdays. Age was categorized as <45, 45–64, and ≥65 years, and urbanization was categorized as urban, suburban, and rural.2324253536 Income status has been considered a critical risk factor for depression, anxiety symptoms, and diabetes4041 andit has also been associated with higher health care utilization and medical expenditures under the NHI program. Therefore, we included income status variables for investigating the association between income levels and health utilization and expenditures. Income level was classified into dependent, <US$666 (NT$20,000), US$666–1332 (NT$20,000–39,999), and ≥US$1333 (≥NT$40,000). In addition, we included individual complications (neurological, peripheral vascular, cardiovascular, renal, endocrinal/metabolic, ophthalmic, and others) based on ICD9-CM diagnosis codes for specifically characterizing patients with diabetes comorbid with and without depression. Detailed ICD-9 diagnosis codes were listed in the Supplementary Table 1 (in the online-only Data Supplement). Finally, we included dummy time variables for each year from 2000 to 2004.
Statistical analyses
Student's t test was used for comparing the differences of health care utilization and expenditures between patients with diabetes comorbid with and without depression each year. After adjustment for time, we primarily identified the NHI 2000 cohort and followed the patients with depression for determining the factors possibly associated with health care utilization and expenditures. General estimation equations (GEE) were used for examining the factors associated with outpatient visits and the total medical expenditure of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression after adjusting for covariates. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used for exploring the associations between the factors of interest and hospitalization of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression. All analyses were performed using SPSS version 12.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
RESULTS
The demographic data of patients with diabetes comorbid with and without depression disorder are shown in Table 1. Health care utilization and expenditures were compared among the two aforementioned cohorts throughout the study period (2000–2004) (Table 2). The average numbers of annual outpatient visits of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression was 44.23 (SD, ±22.96) in 2000 and 52.20 (±32.24) in 2004 and for those without depression were 31.08 (±20.71) in 2000 and 32.92 (±22.74) in 2004. The annual average of hospital admissions for patients with diabetes comorbid with and without depression ranged from 0.93 (SD, ±1.46) to 1.02 (±1.87) and from 0.49 (±1.16) to 0.53 (±1.26), respectively.
The average annual outpatient, inpatient, and total expenditures increased for the two cohorts across the five-year period. The outpatient visits, hospital admission, outpatient expenditures, inpatient expenditures, and total expenditures were significantly higher for patients with diabetes comorbid with depression than for those without depression.
The associations between longitudinal outpatient visits and associated factors analyzed using the GEE model are presented in Table 3. Sex and complications were significant factors in outpatient visits of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression. After adjusting for other covariates, men had 6.27 times less outpatient visits [95% confidence interval (CI): -12.12–-0.42] than did women. Compared with patients without complications, those with ophthalmic complications had 6.04 times more outpatient visits (95% CI: 0.04–12.03).
The factors associated with the total medical expenditures for patients with diabetes comorbid with depression were analyzed using the GEE model (Table 3). Time significantly affected the total medical expenditures of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression. After adjustment for other factors, the total medical expenditures in 2004 were NT$25,837 (95% CI: 7,192–44,483), which is more than that reported in 2000.
The risk of hospitalization in the observation period was analyzed using logistic regression models (Table 4). Urbanization and complications were the significant factors in the hospitalization of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression. After adjustment for other factors, patients living in rural areas had 2.859 times more incidences of hospitalization (95% CI: 1.051–7.777) than their urban counterparts. Compared with patients without complications, those with ophthalmic complications had about 3 times more incidence of hospitalization (95% CI: 1.167–7.720).
DISCUSSION
This study has several key findings. First, compared with diabetic patients without depression, those with depression availed more health care services and had higher expenditures during the study period. These results were consistent with those of previous studies.172728293031 The number of persons with diabetes is also rising because of population growth, aging, urbanization, and increasing prevalence of obesity and physical inactivity. The potential for increase in persons with diabetes is greatest in Asia.811 Type 2 DM has become an important public health threat for the ethnic Chinese population living in mainland China, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Singapore, with a prevalence of one-fifth of the adult population.842 Given the genetic susceptibility and rapid westernization of food and lifestyle, a striking increase in incidence and prevalence of type 2 DM is anticipated.812 Most previous studies were conducted on patients from Western countries and not on those from ethnic Chinese societies. Some differences, including those related with genetic factors, obesity, diet, culture, lifestyle, and medical source, exist between ethnic Chinese societies and Western countries.
Second, the study findings indicated that men used less health care services than women do. The finding is consistent with that of a previous study that reported women as being more capable of identifying depressive symptoms and more willing to seek help.43 In a study in China, the male sex was as sociated with increased direct medical expenditures.44 In addition to sex, ophthalmic complications were associated with increased health care utilization. This finding was consistent with those of previous studies reporting high health care utilization and expenditures of patients with diabetes comorbid with physical complications.19202122
In addition, residing in rural areas and ophthalmic complications were highly associated with hospitalization. This finding was consistent with that of a previous study stating that depressed rural patients had high odds of being hospitalized for physical and mental illnesses.45 Ophthalmic complications are also associated with more health care utilization; this finding was consistent with that of previous studies reporting high health care utilization and expenditures of patients with diabetes comorbid with physical complications.19202122
Investigating health care utilization and expenditure for patients with diabetes comorbid with depression by using an insurance database has many advantages, including a large sample size, less resources required for psychiatric assessments, and the availability of longitudinal data for detecting incidence and risk factors.46
However, this study has several limitations. First, the primary data source in this study was from health insurance claim data. There may exist dual diagnoses, over- and underdiagnoses for billing purposes.34 In addition, some demographic variables, including education, occupation, marital status, lifestyle, physical activity, blood sugar control, and body weight, were also unavailable in the claims database. Third, this study was only adjusted for specific individual complications and not for the overall medical complexity (e.g., Diabetes complication severity index and Charlson comorbidity index) or psychiatric complexity (e.g., diagnosis of anxiety disorders), which are potential confounders. Forth, our study primarily focused on the comparison of health utilization and expenditures between patients with and without general depression disorder. However, future study may further examine the potential difference of health utilization and expenditure between patients with diabetes comorbid with major depression and minor depression. Finally, due to the limitation of data sources, this study can only examine research questions using data from 2000 to 2004. Future study may further examine whether health utilization and expenditures change after a decade among those patients with DM comorbid with and without depression disorders.
Different study designs and instruments may be considered when reviewing health care utilization and expenditures in future studies. ICD-9-CM 296.2x, 296.3x, 296.82, 300.4, 309.0, 309.1, and 311 were included in the definition of depression,23 forming a heterogeneous patient group. Therefore, disorders, commonly comorbid with diabetes, such as MDD, may be compared with the general population in future studies. Furthermore, patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes should be examined. The effects of age, sex, outcomes, complications, and mortality on depression in patients with diabetes should be assessed. Last, continuous NHI follow-up studies are required as references for comparison with future epidemiological studies in this study population.
In conclusion, in this large-scale, population-based study, we revealed the health care utilization and expenditure of patients with diabetes comorbid with depression. Thus far, little research has been conducted for clinical practice with respect to health care utilization and expenditures of such patients in Asia, particularly in China. Our findings indicated that health care utilization and expenditures for patients with diabetes comorbid with depression are significantly higher than those for patients with diabetes without depression. Sex, complications, time, and urbanization are factors associated with health care utilization and expenditures. This study, conducted on patients from ethnic groups in Taiwan, provide valuable epidemiological information.
Acknowledgments
This study was supported by grants from the Kaohsiung Medical University Hospital (KMUH99-9M26) and Kaohsiung Municipal Ta-Tung Hospital (kmtth-100-010 and kmtth-101-013). This study is in part based on data from the National Health Insurance Research Database provided by the Bureau of National Health Insurance, Department of Health and managed by National Health Research Institutes (NHIRD-100-100 and NHIRD-102-135). The interpretation and conclusions contained herein do not represent those of the aforementioned agencies.
References
Supplementary Materials
The online-only Data Supplement is available with this article at https://doi.org/10.4306/pi.2017.14.6.770.